The real problem with the diagnosis of ADHD

The real problem with the diagnosis of ADHD

3 years ago

It’s become a familiar scene now in headlines: Some person misuses a prescribed stimulant medication (usually Adderall) which ends up in a severe tragedy. The news channels pick it up and the story is covered usually the following: The person was diagnosed in less than five minutes in one of the recently popular online formats. Usually a nurse practitioner conducted a brief interview lasting only a few minutes, and establishes a diagnosis of ADHD. Stimulants are prescribed, which then leads to drug abuse or other catastrophes in a toxic soup. Next, everyone becomes and outraged about the over diagnosis of ADHD and the problems with telemedicine.

Each one of these steps are problematic vis-à-vis a correct medical standard, which would include the need for in person evaluations, longer periods of assessment, and the use of clinicians with the highest level of training and experience, such as board-certified psychiatrists.  Even so, most of the time the real problem lies elsewhere. ADHD is not a diagnosis in a vacuum. Most of the time it is accompanied by comorbid conditions such as mood, anxiety, and particularly substance abuse disorders. ADHD itself makes a person prone to addictions and addictive behaviors. The tragic stories are usually the outcome of these poorly evaluated conditions that accompany ADHD or mask themselves as symptoms of ADHD. There are no shortcuts or simple answers to prevent all possible bad outcomes. There are also no alternatives to highly skilled qualified physicians in the fields of psychiatry and neurology to diagnose and treat the challenging condition of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and Attention Deficit Disorder.

We all have multiple facets in our personalities!
We all have multiple facets in our personalities!
7 months ago

For much of my early training, what was then called multiple personality disorder occupied a strange, al...

The Cumulative Trauma of Being a Psychiatrist: The Dark Side of Psychological Transference and Countertransference, and the Burden of the Self
The Cumulative Trauma of Being a Psychiatrist: The Dark Side of Psychological Transference and Countertransference, and the Burden of the Self
11 months ago

Psychiatry, perhaps more than any other medical specialty, is a field defined by ambiguity. Unlike...

Ketamine as an Antidepressant
Ketamine as an Antidepressant
7 years ago

The FDA's approval of esketamine (which is a derivative of the anesthetic drug ketamine) for treatment of depression has been hailed as a ‘game changer’ in the treatment of major de...